Wednesday, March 21, 2007

Girls, Games and Sheri Graner Ray

Game-news site Joystiq has posted coverage of a panel on "Getting Girls into Gaming" which took place recently at the unfolding SXSW conference. Among others, the panel featured game design guru and author Sheri Graner Ray, whose book Gender Inclusive Game Design is next on my comps reading list (just as soon as I finish Allison Druin's The Design of Children's Technology. They discussed a number of issues relating to gender and games, including a thoughtful revisiting of the age old "how do we get girls to play video games" conundrum. From the Joystiq article:
"The panel first asked the question, "What constitutes a female gamer?" Jame Pinckard said, "Women aren't just this monolithic block of 'gamers', they all want different types of games. Just because a Barbie video is made for a 12 year old girl, doesn't mean a 26 year woman has to play it." Sheri Graner Ray took it a step further, adding "There is no definition of a female gamer, and trying to tack a label to them does a disservice. The female gamer is simply a female who plays games. She's just a diverse as any other market out there.""

The panel (and article) also pointed out that although 42% of online gamers are female, the fact that this stat includes casual games obscures significant under-representation of female players in areas like online console gaming (where they make up only 2%). They also discussed the trickier aspects of approaching "girl games" and the desire to attract the female demographic as a problem that can be solved through focus groups and statistics. As Pinkard highlights:
"The majority of game publishers and developers are male, and when they try to make games for female gamers, they use things like focus groups and research numbers. As a result, they usually miss the target and develop games for them that suck. Then the games don't sell, so the publishers say, "Well, women don't play games."

Of course, the same problem doesn't usually exist for "boy games", since the developers probably approach these in a more open, "let's make an awesome game" kind of way.

The article theorizes that girls and guys like the same kinds of games (which is certainly the case for some and certainly not the case for others) and narrow it down to a marketing problem...though I think that what they're pointing at is actually problems with the way that gaming is framed within society. Which could certainly be a contributing factor, though I can't say that I agree with this as a conclusion.

Tuesday, March 20, 2007

Assembly Bill 1392 and In-Game Spyware

Short entry today for a change. I just found out that California assemblywoman Lori SaldaƱa went ahead and introduced a bill last month (introduced on the 23rd, and first read on the 26th of February 2007) aimed at strengthening existing online privacy laws, which would potentially include new rules about the use of spyware in online games. Assembly Bill 1392 is scheduled to be heard in committee on March 27th. As it stands, the bill is exceedingly vague - read it here - but it will be interesting to see what develops during the committee hearing next week.

Monday, March 19, 2007

Publishing and The Peer Review

Our grad secretary sent out a link today to a pretty cool online resource for (Canadian) grad students called The Peer Review, that includes an excellent article on publishing as a grad student called The Ultimate Guide to Scholarly Publishing. Here are some highlights/key points from the article that I think are of particular importance to grad students trying to get their work published:

When to Publish:
"[T]he most important thing is to start the process early as possible. One thing many students don’t get their head around, Freeman explains, is that when you are admitted to graduate studies, it is because of your potential, but your ongoing progress is based on your accomplishment."

Picking a Journal 1:
"When choosing where to publish, the key is to match the publication and the quality of your work. [...] It’s great if you can get into the most prestigious journal in your field, but the main goal should be to work progressively to a goal: "stay productive, be out there, be putting your work out in places that people can see it and often that means in a variety of places.""

Picking a Journal 2:
"The easiest way to know if your work will fit in a particular journal is to read the journal. "Why on earth would you submit to a journal you don’t read?" asks Freeman. If you read a journal, it is likely that you not only have a sense of the type of research it publishes, but also some of the finer points of its style."

The Three Keys to Editing your Submission:
- Quality: "It’s amazing the number of articles that get tossed out at the beginning because the quality is just so poor,"" [...] "The less editors need to work on your piece, the more likely it is to get selected for publication."

- Clarity: ""What did you do? Why did you do it? What does your study or idea contribute to what we already know about the subject? State this clearly in the abstract, introduction and cover letter...""

- Context: ""If there is one mistake authors make, it is not to describe the big picture," says Dhand. "What is known, what this piece of work is adding to the field and how this can be applied or take the field further.""

Making Sense of Peer Review Comments:
"[F]eedback is sometimes totally tactless because reviewers are in a hurry. And note that ‘revise and resubmit’ does not mean ‘reject.’ It’s very common for a paper to be accepted contingent on minor changes. Or, they may just say revise and resubmit, and then you will need to find out if it has been accepted, provided the changes are made, or if it must enter the review process again."

Publishing as a Process:
"There is no great mystery to the process, it just seems mysterious because it is drawn out, and can be derailed by any number of very tiny mistakes, errors that are not just technical, like poor editing, but also mental mistakes — assuming, for instance, that harsh comments mean there is little hope for your work..."

The Process of Publishing:
"...journals are picky, reviewers are overworked, publication schedules are slow, and competition is plentiful. If your work is of relevance and importance, you can be assured that there is a journal that will publish it."

To all this I would add that getting involved in the peer review process directly is also a great way to dispel some of your more primal fears about the whole thing. Seeing how it all works from the perspective of a peer reviewer can really help you to identify areas in your own work that might need tweaking/development, to understand the context from which comments and revisions are drawn, and to develop more sympathy/patience for the length of time it can take for the reviewers and editors to get back to you.

On a personal note, I want to wish the best of luck to my partner and colleague Anil Narine who is commencing his week-long comprehensive exams today!!!

Sunday, March 18, 2007

Life Lessons from the Pussycat Dolls

I've been trying to ignore this new reality show called Pussycat Dolls Present: The Search for the Next Doll which premiered on CW earlier this month...hopefully for obvious reasons. It seems, however, that I was one of the few of my demographic who did - MediaLife magazine reports that the show has averaged a 3.2 rating among women aged 18-34. More importantly (to me anyway), is the fact that it averaged 4.3 among teenage girls ages 12-17. The article offers a few theories about why that might be--aside from the obvious, that the Pussycat Dolls are a pretty wildly popular group right now, especially among teen demos. Or the enumerable similarities this new show shares with teen/cult favourite America's Next Top Model--it even repeated directly following ANTM a couple of weeks ago. No, MediaLife thinks that the show is popular because of its "empowering" qualities - an absolutely chilling possibility. They write [and I've inserted my own comments in brackets like this one]:
"There are several likely reasons [why the show is so popular among teen girls], and the first is that the show is aspirational, in the way that magazines like Fitness and Seventeen are [!]. They see in the group and the wannabes fit bodies [the majority of the contestants have professional dance training] and the latest look [more on this later]. They see the latest dance steps [hmmm - for strippers perhaps]. And they see their self-confidence, which is hugely impressive for girls at an age when self-doubt is the norm [see below]. They see role models."

Intrigued and disgusted, I sat down this afternoon to watch a repeat of last week's episode. This particular episode was, fittingly, all about confidence--how some girls have too much of it (and are therefore doomed to fail), and how some girls are seriously lacking in it (and therefore malleable to the show's objectives of "empowering female sexuality" - hmmm). The judges decided to teach the candidates about "confidence" during a night out at a Hollywood restaurant by giving them a surprise challenge after (perhaps during?) dinner--to put on lingerie and stripper dance (sans actually removing any clothing--not that there was much to remove) in boudoir-styled window boxes in front of the entire restaurant. Surprise! It looked like something out of a red light district in Amsterdam, and was particularly painful to watch after hearing the contestants' initial shock at even being IN a restaurant with, to paraphrase one of the girls, "half-naked ladies dancing above the bar".

The show ended with the elimination of the girl with "too much confidence"--it was getting in the way of her performance in that the judges thought she danced and looked "too much" like a stripper, and not enough like a sophisticated Pussycat Doll. Yikes! This show comes from the same IP that wanted to market Pussycat Dolls dolls to 6-year-olds (they backed off after major public outcry). And while MediaLife doesn't report on the tween demographic, these past initiatives make me seriously wonder how much spill-over there is into younger female audience segments. The show is a must-see, unfortunately, for those of you interested in girls' culture, though on the bright side it does provide PLENTY of fodder for academic analysis.

Friday, March 16, 2007

Exergaming in Texas

Jason Dobson has written a piece over at the Serious Games Source on a new partnership between Konami (makers of Dance Dance Revolution) and a new chain of "child focused" fitness clubs in Texas called NexGym. As part of the deal, Konami wil be installing Dance Dance Revolution games at all future NexGym locations. Dobson writes,
"As part of the agreement, children between the ages of 3-14 will be able to take advantage of the health and fitness benefits of Dance Dance Revolution at all Nexgym locations during interactive classes and open gym “exer-gaming” sessions. Konami will also promote DDR tournament events at existing Nexgym locations and in connection with future Nexgym grand openings.

NexGym, which opened its second location in Texas earlier this year, distinguishes itself by offering interactive classes and programs for children ages 3-14 and exergaming programs featuring video game and virtual exercise technology equipment designed specifically for kids 6-14. Nexgym also offers “Xtreme Birthday Parties” with a focus on fun and fitness, as well as programs for children with special needs, nutritional guidance and custom fitness programs for children."


The concept of gyms for kids is pretty intriguing, as is the idea of "exergaming" programs. Going to the gym IS pretty boring, not to mention the fact that most of the activities and machines there are oriented pretty purely towards adult physiology, so I definitely see why a new format--combining more aerobic activities and, well, fun--would be necessary. Less than a year old, NexGym (formerly Energym) represents the first official gyms-for-kids chain that I've heard of. While both existing branches were opened in Texas, the company plans to open 10 new locations over the coming year. The company is banking on a couple of things. First is the growing likelihood that parental concern about soaring child obesity rates will soon create a significant consumer demand (perhaps even in lieu of citizen demand) that options such as these be made available. The second is that the western focus on "rational" or instrumental play as ideal play will provide the illusion that regimented, technologically-enabled fun represents the surest way towards better health--both physical and mental. The website reflects this focus on its "About" page:
"Nexgym is the leader in the growing trend in kids fitness. With an ever-increasing population of children who are unfit expanding across North America, the time is right to provide a facility which has the right technology to engage children, a precise understanding of children and their needs, and an exclusive brand and image which brings the concept to life."

Now, I am NOT going to complain about a facility that provides kids with a greater number of exercise alternatives, particularly one that emphasizes kids' having fun as much as it does other health benefits, but there are a couple of things here that deserve noting. What concerns me most is that commercial entities are once again at the forefront in providing kids with the spaces and tools they are most lacking in other areas of life--in this case play spaces and pro-social technologies that at least initially seem responsive to (some of) kids' own needs when it comes to physical activity and exercise (it's missing cooperative play/team sports and fresh air, but it's a start). As citizens of a theoretically democratic and socially-responsive government, Texans and Americans should take one look at this initiative and wonder why the school systems (like the one in West Virginia) and health departments aren't offering similar kinds of programs for free (or at least at a subsidized cost). Knowing that obesity is tightly linked to class and socio-economic status, a highly specialized fitness center that charges a $49/month membership fee + additional fees for things like karate lessons and yoga might just be an indication of a new form of emerging social stratification based around access to health/fitness knowledge and opportunities.

As for the concept of "exergaming" and what it could mean in relation to theories around rationalized play, I definitely see a great opportunity for an extension of "ludification" theory, but will have to think it over a little more before making an approach.

Thursday, March 15, 2007

The French Democracy

Very cool article in this week's Escapist by Allen Varney about last year's machinima hit The French Democracy, and the particular copyright issues raised by machinima as an emerging art form. He writes,
If you shoot a high-def film with a Canon camera, Canon doesn't own your movie. If you publish a book or magazine that uses fonts owned by Microsoft and images corrected in Adobe Photoshop, neither Microsoft nor Adobe owns your publication, because their licenses specifically grant you ownership. But if you make a machinima film using The Movies, Activision (the publisher) controls it. Activision controls everything.

This is a must-read for anyone interested in digital IP issues and/or user-generated content. It offers a great summary of the particular legal/ethical issues associated with machinima, concentrating on Activison's The Movies as a sort of case study. My law professor (and author of Video Game Law) Jon Festinger pointed out this game as a potential locus of future (digital) IP debates, and Varney seems to agree that a machinima-centred IP conflict may yet come to pass, although perhaps not for some time:
Copyright problems aside, it's hard to envision a machinima movement with political clout. What is the usual fate of a political work produced outside the existing power structure? Such works aren't inherently, inevitably marginalized, but history shows that's the way to bet. "The French Democracy" is to machinima as, say, Democracy Now is to American television. They are both commentators in the wilderness, exiled by systemic pressures that have no technical fix.

You can read the full article here.

Tuesday, March 13, 2007

300 and the Female Anomaly

Unless you've been sleeping under a rock for the past three days, you already know that Zack Snider's spectacular adaptation of Frank Miller's graphic novel 300 is a massive success, earning more than $70 million on its first weekend (I saw it on Sunday!). What does this have to do with Gamine Expedition, you might ask? Well, while the film doesn't fall under my usual focus on kids' culture and videogames, 52% of those who saw it over the weekend WERE under the age of 25, which certainly makes it part of youth culture. But more significantly I've been really fascinated by the press and industry attempts to make sense of the film's success, which seem to reproduce those found within comparable analyses of the video game industry - namely, sticking to their stereotype-guns when it comes to notions of the gendered audience.

It seems that the audience for 300 this past weekend was both slightly younger and much more 'female' than the industry expected it to be. Surprisingly (well, not really) this isn't driving the "experts" to rethink their gender assumptions when it comes to highly-stylized action films (like 300, Sin City, Kill Bill, etc.) - instead, they've somehow found a way to make the numbers fit into the same old worn-out gendered templates of "fanboys on the Internet" and "girls remaining faithful to their heartthrob." Case in point, the LA Times reported today on the "fanboy" power behind the film's success, which was further enabled by those fountains of buzz "viral marketing" and "MySpace":
Fanboy buzz is not enough to sell a film -- "Snakes on a Plane," anyone? -- but Garabedian points out that while the online community was obsessively talking about "Snakes" they were ultimately making fun of it. The people who were driving the chatter around "300" were genuinely excited about the film, especially the way it looked. And after Comic-Con, Warner Bros. marketing department made sure that the fanboys got the usual dribs and drabs of movie art and trailers just to keep their excitement up.

The marketing folks also took full advantage of MySpace. There was of course the requisite MySpace page for the film (now standard for all movies) -- featuring a ferocious looking muscle man in a metal helmet plus tons of video clips, wallpapers and links to the film's official website. But the stroke of genius came when the studio sponsored a feature upgrade to the site that told users they could store 300 photos on their profile thanks to the movie "300." (Previously the limit had been 12). That started Jan. 2 and was incredibly popular with teens. The result was billions of ad impressions and 8 million viewings of the trailer. Is it any wonder that the 52% of the people who saw "300" were under 25?


Eek! Contrast this to this item from ScifiWire, which put forth its interpretation of the film's then-anticipated success among the female audience couple of days ago:
Zack Snyder, director of the upcoming graphic-novel adaptation 300, told SCI FI Wire that he was caught off guard by the number of women who want to see the film, which is an action-packed R-rated sword-and-sandals epic. The reason is simple: Gerard Butler.

Snyder said he was "surprised" by the strong following among women of Butler, who stars as Spartan King Leonidas. "I knew that there were these women [who] loved Gerry, but ... who could ever know?" he said in bewilderment in an interview at WonderCon in San Francisco last weekend.

Indeed, most of the questions addressed to the 300 panel at WonderCon came from female fans of Butler's, many of whom run Web sites devoted to the hunky Scottish actor. It also came as a surprise that fans will see Butler in any film, no matter the genre; Butler has appeared in films as diverse as Phantom of the Opera and Dear Frankie.

So, despite the fact that this is Butler's first big film, we are to somehow believe that his female fan base is so dedicated that they will make sure to see him "in any film, no matter the genre", and large enough to make a significant dent in the boxoffice figures. What this basically amounts to is explaining away women's/girls' excitement for 300 as an anomaly - one that finds its true source in female fans' worship of Butler and their desire to maintain an audience "relationship" of sorts with this particular actor...no matter the genre (a.k.a. even genres that are otherwise "not for them"). Instead of trying to expand or dispel existing (narrow) notions that "what women want" out of films are romantic comedies and relationship dramas, they seem to have found a way to merely reproduce these notions within a slightly different context. Even though women are obviously watching horror and action movies in great numbers (just look at the success of LOTR and the superhero movies).

This immediately reminds me of T.L.Taylor's discussion of gender and games in her book Play Between Worlds, and how female gamers are viewed by industry and academics as "anomalies"--not representative of the larger female population, because they are drawn to media content that is also "not for them," and therefore not worthy of serious consideration if the object is to understand what would attract more female players to videogames. In their quest to maintain these categories, the media is truly missing out on opportunities to both create better quality content and reach a larger a.k.a. more diverse audience.

Friday, March 09, 2007

New Developments on the US Regulatory Front

As reported by the KidAdLaw.com website, two important reports pertaining to kids and media in the US were recently presented to Congress. The first consists of a five-year progress report on COPPA by the FTC, which maintains that (as reported by KidAdLaw) the COPPA rules:

[H]ave been effective in protecting the privacy and security of young children online without unduly burdening Web site operators. The report does not recommend any changes to COPPA or to the Commission’s Rule, but does note that, because widespread age verification technology is not available, age falsification remains a risk on general audience Web sites not intended for children’s use. The report also identifies social networking sites and mobile Internet access as new andemerging issues in children’s online privacy.

I love how the FTC both blames kids for existing inadequacies in the system ("age falsification"), all the while claiming that although social networking and wireless access present "new and emerging issues" the current rules somehow don't need updating. The FTC also seems kind of impressed that children's websites have come up with such innovative ways of making money off kids without collecting much "personally identifiable" data. *Sigh* They are the "Trade" commission after all, but this just goes to show that privacy and commerce aren't really issues that should fall under the authority of the same governing body.

The second report was presented by the FCC, who are continuing their campaign to tighten regulation on violent television content, in particular during family and child-heavy viewing times. They're now claiming that violent content can be regulated in a similar manner as sexual content (the old "violence as porn" argument - I'm having a bit of deja vu here), which would somehow mean it could occur without infringing upon First Amendment rights. I don't really understand how that works, but it keeps coming up in the video game cases as well so there must be SOME sort of logic behind it (though it would seem that in the states censorship is always censorship...only unless it involves sex). According to KidAdLaw:
The FCC report states that Congress could pass a law that would authorize the agency to regulate violent content during the hours that children watch TV, just as sexual content and profanity are restricted. The report concludes that there is “strong evidence” that violent media can impact children’s behavior, Chairman Martin told the AP.

The site also has a number of new and interesting articles (and links) discussing the massive impact of the UK's recent media ban on advertising unhealthy foods to kids. Check out some of the coverage here and here. I'm really liking this new resource, especially since you can sign up for email updates which they send every couple of weeks or so. It's certainly maintaining its industry focus, but it's nonetheless very thorough in keeping up-to-date on developments as well as public + press reactions to new laws and policies.

Thursday, March 08, 2007

Further Thoughts on Okami

The winners of this year's Game Developers Choice Awards were announced today, with Gears of War picking up a number of awards, including Game of the Year. While Okami unfortunately wasn't picked for Game of the Year as I had hoped, it did win for Best Character Design (yay Amaterasu!), and received an award for Innovation (along with Wii Sports and a Flash game called Line Rider...what a great year this has been for the game industry!). And now that I'm about halfway through the game myself (it took my game-tester roommate over 40 hours to complete, and I'm only about 22 hours in), I can say with certainty that Okami deserved that and a lot more.

The experience of playing Okami is unique and strangely uplifting (to read an overview of the plot and some coverage of critical reception of the game, check out the Wikipedia entry). I never could have imagined how enjoyable it is to experience running around the countryside as a goddess in wolf-form, restoring life to dead trees and polluted pastures, freeing and feeding the wildlife (who fall in love with you as a result), leaving in my wake an endless stream of flowers and leaves instead of the usual piles of bloody corpses. While the emphasis is on creativity, there is certainly conflict and a large battle aspect to the gameplay - and Amaterasu is equipped with some handy weapons and excellent fight moves with which to conquer enemies. But much of the gameplay, including battles, relies on your skills with a paintbrush - with which you sort of "interrupt" the game, which then reveals itself as an ancient scroll. Once you've extracted yourself to this meta-level, you are then able to simply "draw in" desired narrative turns or devices based on a series of brush strokes you learn over the course of the game. Thus, you can use the brush to "slash" your enemies, or draw a stream of water from a nearby river to extinguish a fire-demon, or draw a sun in the sky to illuminate your path. As a result, you're constantly reminded of your concurrent roles as a character AND as an author of the game narrative and experience. As a goddess, you are both of the universe of the game but also above it - which is a great, reflexive subject position to provide for a video game player who is already occupying these concurrent roles, though not always this explicitly.

The game itself is quite immense, with many areas to explore and revisit again once new skills (i.e. brush strokes) are acquired. The first half of the game revolves around the return of an old enemy that (according to the ancient myth, in all its ambiguity and contradicting versions) Amaterasu helped to vanquish 100 years ago, who is now back to re-attempt domination of medieval Nippon. The surprising thing is, while the plot leads up to an eventual re-match that at first seems to signify the end of the game, you soon find out that the "end" is not the end, but simply the first albeit major step in a much larger quest. Now presented with an overarching quest of undefined scope and even content, you are reassured by several characters that when faced with a seemingly insurmountable task, your best bet is to tackle it one component at a time...much like a PhD, or a comprehensive exam reading list. The gender representation is a bit tongue in check - our travel companion is a bug-sized "lady's man" who incessantly hits on the beautiful sprites and big-breasted priestesses we encounter throughout our journey. Amaterasu herself is apparently quite beautiful - you occasionally encounter someone who can see your true form - although the avatar is (so far) solely represented as a stately white wolf...though I'm sure there will be some kind of "reveal" by the end of the game. Overall, though, I've found that these elements are treated with humor and again with reflexivity, this time on the genre conventions of fantasy/adventure video games (well, video games in general).

More to come once I've completed the game in full. So far, though, Okami is headed to my list of favourite games of all time for its innovative and unique gameplay experience, stunning graphics, and engaging gender-inclusive narrative.

Tuesday, March 06, 2007

LEGO MMOG (that's a lot of capital letters) Announced

From The Escapist Daily, an announcement from LEGO that they have selected NetDevil to assist in the building of their upcoming MMOG/persistent environment. From The Escapist blurb:

"The LEGO brand represents construction, creativity, and problem solving, and the LEGO Group would like to develop new and engaging ways for fans to interact with the LEGO brand as children around the world spend more time online," said Lisbeth Valther Pallesen, the Executive Vice President, Community, Education, and Direct Division LEGO Group.

She went on to remark that the massively multiplayer online market can merge online social interaction and physical play which will provide new experiences for children and LEGO enthusiasts alike.

As LEGO already runs a highly successful family of websites/online games/online communities, not to mention the highly popular LEGO Star Wars games, they seem well suited to this particular type of endeavour. I'm pretty interested in the said "merging" of social interaction and physical play--presumably with real LEGO sets, which necessarily implies purchase. The LEGO games already represent a somewhat abstracted example of advergaming--while there is no doubt that there is massive branding and even UGC appropriation going on, it's been difficult to define how this is different from any other media-branded game or cross-media initiative. Is it enough that certain characters are present in a game to argue that it works to promote other products featuring those same characters or narratives? (I say yes!) Must there be a link to a specific set of products? (No, but it's easier to get other people on board when there is!) Branding is such a difficult issue in kids' media - it sometimes seems like there is little else out other than (cross-)branding.

In other news, the Corus/YTV MMOG is up and running, under the name GalaxSeeds, which you can check out here. I haven't played it yet, but will surely be blogging about it within the next few days.

Monday, March 05, 2007

Child-Generated Content as Media Fad or Technologized Play?

There's a provocative think-piece in today's KidScreen Daily written by John Marley (a series producer at UK-based Talent Kids, creators of Best of Friends) on child-generated content and Nickelodeon's recent ME:TV announcement. His main argument is that although children are early adopters, they are also early abandoners when it comes to new media fads, which (according to him) makes it unlikely that user-generated content will be all that successful as a media strategy targeted toward the younger demographics. Marley lists several previous attempts to use UGC-television programming in the past, and describes the fickleness of the "multiplatform" generation. He then goes on to conclude:

I can understand why commissioners can get dazzled by the idea of getting kids to provide editorial content. It's cheaper, you can own the rights in every format in perpetuity [**SMG winces**] and, if they film it, it must - as I mentioned earlier - resonate with them, right?
[...]
[W]hile there is still a certain cachet for those kids lucky enough to actually see themselves on TV, the rise of home video and webcam has slightly dulled this as a motivator. In a kid's mind these days, it's only exciting to be seen on TV arriving somewhere swish in a limo, being chased by the paparazzi!

Now if, as a producer, you package that thing correctly for them, then you could have a hit on your hands. The user-generated prospect that will work best for the kids' audience, I believe, is one that springs from a larger back concept that will already have some appeal in the minds of children. Get them hooked into a back story, and then you can shape the content with which they start to provide you. That way you are more likely to get footage that will be genuinely "on message" for your audience and hopefully make for good content.


I can't help but agree to some extent with Marley's valuation of "UGC" (or CGC as I like to call it when the users are children) as quite the hype-magnet right now. Reading the industry literature on the "vast potential" of UGC, where potential always means either profits or branding or market research data (these last two in the hopes of eventual profits), it's often puzzled me where and how exactly the industry thinks they can make any real money off the common vlog or machinima. Of course, television, magazines and newspapers all make their real profits from selling advertising space, so perhaps this can translate into the YouTubes and XNA Game Studio Expresses, but doesn't THAT sound a bit like the net-bubble of the late-1990s? I agree with Marley's conclusion that Nickelodeon is going to need more than just a toolset for kids to upload home-videos to draw in an audience of any significance or shelf life. His notion of providing the "back story" or a narrative umbrella is one currently used by Zimmer Twins, and provides the rationale for the new TV-themed MMOGs I've been blogging about. This could certainly be one way of harnessing kids' (well, users generally) propensity for appropriating and playing with media-brands.

In this respect, perhaps Marley is looking at this from the wrong perspective. Can we really compare UGC/CGC to the more "passive" forms of media consumption of yesteryear? Why try to integrate these experiences? There is an audience aspect to CGC (well, the possibility of one anyway), but perhaps Marley's focus should remain on the production angle and on understanding what this is really an extension of. Is it an extension of television watching (consumption)? Or is it perhaps better understood as a digital networking of creative activities (production) like and including fan-fiction and branded play? And from this perspective, nothing is more effective or engrossing for kids than playing and creating with others - CGC may not "replace" television watching, but it may very well extend and technologize (and eventually mediatize) the creative play practices that make up a big part of their everyday lives. The problem is that television profits necessarily derive from the "audience commodity," to the point that even UGC/CGC must somehow (for the current business models to continue working and generating profit) come down to audiences and consumption. The shift to the "prosumer" and the "audience/user as producer" shakes this up at such a fundamental level--it's fascinating to see how the media industries scramble to adapt, even while failing to shift their own mode of thought away from traditional models.

Saturday, March 03, 2007

Happy Birthday Dr. Seuss!

It was Theodor Geisel's (a.k.a. Dr. Seuss) birthday yesterday, and the 50th anniversary of The Cat in the Hat the day before that. Like so many people with an interest in children's media, Dr. Seuss holds a special place in my heart as one of those rare beacons of light (along with Jim Henson, Fred Rogers, Ernie Coombs and Judy Bloom) in what can often seem like a veritable quagmire of low-quality production and exploitative commercialization. His interest in speaking to children on their own terms, in teaching even very small kids about human rights, self-respect and sustainable living--all the while making us laugh and exploding our imaginations wide open with new words, sounds and insights--continues to inspire and set a high standard for what a children's media professional can and should be.

Resources:
Philip Nel (2005) Dr. Seuss: American Icon. Continuum.

Phillip Nel (2003). "The Disneyfication of Dr Seuss: faithful to profit, one hundred percent?" Cultural Studies 17(5): 579-614.

Richard H.F. Lindemann (2005). The Dr. Seuss Catalog: An Annotated Guide to Works by Theodor Geisel in All Media, Writings about Him, and Appearances of Characters and Places in the Books, Stories and Films. McFarland Company.

Seussville.com

Or listen to this awesome mashup, Dylan Hears A Who

Thursday, March 01, 2007

Tools of the Trade: Databases and Style Guides

Just a quick post today about some new research tools that I find exciting these days. The first is a new style guide coming out this year called Wired Style: The Videogame Style Guide and Reference Manual, written by David Thomas, Kyle Orland (of Joystiq) and Scott Steinberg, that promises to offer guidance on "spelling conventions and game criticism, plus company information and historical timelines" for the videogames industry. According to Orland, the manual will provide:
[S]ome consistent answers for those niggling copy editing questions that constantly come up when writing about games -- questions like whether videogame should be one word or two (the guide says one, you say two), whether to capitalize the B in Xbox (no) and whether the term "Wiimote" should be excised from the English language forever (yes, yes, a thousand times yes).

You can read some preview coverage of the manual at Joystiq here, and at GamesIndustry.biz here.

In other news, I've been hearing a lot about a new web-based reference database called Zotero that I'm pretty excited to try out and possibly integrate into my data-collection for my thesis research. Here's a brief description from the website:
Zotero is a free, easy-to-use research tool that helps you gather and organize resources (whether bibliography or the full text of articles), and then lets you to annotate, organize, and share the results of your research. It includes the best parts of older reference manager software (like EndNote)—the ability to store full reference information in author, title, and publication fields and to export that as formatted references—and the best parts of modern software such as del.icio.us or iTunes, like the ability to sort, tag, and search in advanced ways. Using its unique ability to sense when you are viewing a book, article, or other resource on the web, Zotero will—on many major research sites—find and automatically save the full reference information for you in the correct fields.

It's currently in the Beta stage, but already looks very impressive, as you can see from this online demo. Plus it's compatible with EndNote, the program that I'm currently using to organize and manage my references and comp notes, so this might be just the ticket to integrating online sources into my existing system.

Wednesday, February 28, 2007

ESRB Ratings System Revamp

Having recently watched the wonderful documentary This Film is Not Yet Rated (a behind-the-scenes look at the American movie ratings system, the MPAA), I can't help but be skeptical of the ESRB's (Entertainment Software Ratings Board) recent announcement that they are revamping their own ratings process to better address, well, content. The big news here is that they've decided to hire full-time raters, which will allow them to now play the games themselves instead of relying on game companies to self-report potentially objectionable content. Both GamePolitics.com and Joystiq have been following this development closely, and you can read some of their articles here and here.

Obviously, it's high time that this switch was made. It's hard to believe that the Board was able to claim objective and accurate ratings based solely on a few clips and game companies' varied (and, yes, subjective) understandings of what the Board would qualify as violent, sexual, etc. content. It made me think about the MPAA, however, and the types of people that make up THEIR ratings team - in This Film is Not Yet Rated, they discovered that the vast majority were middle-aged parents of adult children (and not parents of children between the ages of 5 and 17, as the MPAA suggests), and typically quite middle/upper-middle class (they didn't explore this in too much detail, but the size of their houses and the small salary attached to the position of 'rater' strongly suggests supplementary income). They sit around watching movies all day, taking notes, discussing content, and then vote on a rating.

I just don't think that this same approach is going to work with video games, namely because of the demographics and nature of gameplay. While the average age of a digital game player is 29, the average age of console players and players of games that would require the more-thorough playthrough in the first place (i.e. NOT casual games or online Solitaire, etc.), is surely much lower. And the pool of qualified people - assuming they're looking for raters who are already know how to play videogames (and hopefully are good enough to get through long games and learn the various different control configurations) and not planning on sending new raters to some sort of video game boot camp (which I doubt would really work that well) - is much smaller (and male dominated, which is another issue altogether). I guess what I'm trying to say is that I just don't think it's likely that the same type of people that currently decide on film ratings would be willing or able to play 20+ hours of a game in order to rate it. This could mean a much different set of criteria and demographics for the ESRB raters, and I really wonder if this will change the general tone of the ESRB or its resultant ratings in the future.

Tuesday, February 27, 2007

New Articles in The Escapist...& Feminist Media Studies

The new issue of The Escapist is out today, featuring a selection of "editor's picks" (articles that didn't play well with the other issues) including an article written by me (yay!) about the topic of my MA research, datamining in kids' advergames. This article is the culmination of quite a bit of hard work - I contacted the magazine's editors last spring to see if they'd be interested in publishing me (and sort of kept pestering them until they agreed), while the article itself is quite a divergence from the style and voice that you become used to as an academic. It was a long road, but one that I'm immensely happy and proud to have taken, as this represents my first professional publication outside of academia. A big thanks to Russ Pitts and the editorial team at The Escapist for giving me this unique opportunity.
Check it out yourself by clicking here.

In a second item of good news (shesh!), the online discussion on Digital Games and Gender I participated in last fall with Helen Kennedy and Mia Consalvo has been published as the "Commentary and Criticism" section of the latest issue of Feminist Media Studies journal. (Subscription is probably required to access the article online)

Monday, February 26, 2007

Child-Generated Content Gets Televised

This news item appeared in KidScreen Daily last week, written by Gary Rusak:

February 19, 1007: Nickelodeon is launching a new TV block...that draws from online counterpart Nick.com. For two hours every weekday from 5 p.m. to 7 p.m., Nickelodeon's Me:TV will feature content uploaded by audience members to its main website.

Hosted by Alexandra Gizela and Jordan Carlos, the block features four kids live on-air via webcam, online voting, gaming, giveaways and celebrity guests. It takes cues from current Nick shows U-Pick Live and Slimetime Live, using a live studio audience and kid participation through instant messaging, phone calls and internet message boards to up the interactive quotient. Kids are encouraged to submit their videos to www.nick.com/metv, where they will be rated and shared by the community, Ć  la YouTube. Unlike the adult-oriented site, however, Me:TV is being heavily monitored and moderated, and the net requires parental permission before it will put any user-generated content on air.

On a related note, YTV will once again hold its Spring Break Show-down, allowing kids to pick what programs will air over their spring break and getting them to vote for favourite shows, etc.

Sunday, February 25, 2007

Angelina Ballerina and Barbie Hit the Stage

This is a pretty cute story about a co-venture in the UK between HIT Entertainment and the English National Ballet to bring popular children's character-brand Angelina Ballerina to the real life stage. From the ballet troupe's press release:
Angelina’s Star Performance brings the magic of Angelina Ballerina to life in her first live performance on stage. The production features a cast of eight dancers from English National Ballet with over 100 performances over three weeks in 20 venues across the UK. [...] Angelina’s Star Performance will be a special introduction to ballet for children from the age of 3+ and the tour will be complemented by an education programmed designed to give children the opportunity to experience ballet. The performances will also feature fun activities and workshops in the venues including the opportunity to take part in Angelina Ballerina Dance Academy™ classes.

A similar kind of venture was recently attempted in the US, where you can now catch the Columbus Symphony Orchestra playing live renditions of famous songs included in the Barbie ballet movies, while scenes from the films are projected overhead. The idea behind both projects is to introduce a new generation of youngsters to traditional cultural forms, in this case the symphony and the ballet. Of course, the idea is also to introduce a new level of commercialization to yet another aspect of cultural life. I suppose both parties are getting something out of it - but for the kids watching these productions (or participating in a media-branded ballet class - eek!), it's above all just another case of brand expansion.

To find out about Barbie/Mattel's ongoing relationship with the New York City Ballet, read this!

Thursday, February 22, 2007

Sexualization of Girls in the Media

The American Psychological Association (APA) released a new report earlier this week about the on-going sexualization of young girls in advertising, merchandising and the media. In a press release on the reports' findings, Dr. Eileen L. Zurbriggen, a representative of the APA Task Force on Sexualization, states:
“The consequences of the sexualization of girls in media today are very real and are likely to be a negative influence on girls’ healthy development. We have ample evidence to conclude that sexualization has negative effects in a variety of domains, including cognitive functioning, physical and mental health, and healthy sexual development.”

The Task Force has defined sexualization "as occurring when a person’s value comes only from her/his sexual appeal or behavior, to the exclusion of other characteristics, and when a person is sexually objectified, e.g., made into a thing for another’s sexual use." Their study included an extensive review of published articles examining the contents and effects of a variety of media and marketing, as well as family and peer influence. As with other APA literature reviews into media effects, the report does not argue causality, but does conclude that a link (correlation) is likely and therefore supports reduced exposure and increased parental intervention (such as media education).

I particularly like the way the APA has included products and marketing discourse in its review, as seen in this article about inappropriately sexy children's toys (such as Bratz dolls). They seem to be approaching the issue in a comprehensive way, demonstrating how a coherent and near-ubiquitous message of sexualization can be found across the gamut of children's (and particularly girls') culture--from toys and clothing, to media and public discourse, to peer groups and how the issues are addressed at home. It's much more convincing than a mere media effects model (which sometimes tries to isolate influence), primarily because it tries to take into account the way in which we experience the media as (more or less) integrated elements of our particular cultural environment...instead of as a series of somewhat distinct relationships.

Anyway, there seems to be a lot going on around this topic these days, with a high profile lawsuit in Australia involving a left-wing think tank's claims that retailer David Jones sexually exploits children in its ads. This will be the first time the issue of sexualization in advertising has been considered by a court, so it will be interesting to see how it all turns out. There are also a number of books coming out, both academic and general interest, including one co-authored by Jean Kilbourne and Diane Levin (planned title: So Sexy, So Soon), as well as one by Sharon Lamb and Lyn Mikel Brown entitled Packaging Girlhood: Rescuing our daughters from marketers' schemes (available now). For a great look at the history of eroticization and sexualization of young girls in Western popular culture, I recommend Valerie Walkerdine's wonderfully provocative book Daddy's Girl: Young Girls and Popular Culture.

Tuesday, February 20, 2007

Trend Watch: Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Merchandising Bonanza

The new Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles computer-animated movie is coming out on March 23, amidst a stunningly comprehensive cross-promotion/merchandising bonanza that will attempt to revive the brand to its glory days of yore. One of my most vivid memories of the original TMNT toy fad from the 80s and early 90s involves the release of the second feature film, green popcorn at the cinema (even Maniwaki did not escape THAT grosserific promotional stunt), and an extended period of wearing our karate gui at inappropriate times to make sure everyone knew that we, too, were Ninjas. Everyone had a favourite Turtle (Donatello!), and there was a unique kind of frenzy around the brand that I do not remember really ever experiencing before TMNT.

While a television show based on the original hit series has aired on Saturday Mornings over the past couple of years with some success, the brand has yet to reproduce that same level of frenzy among today's youth. As with many of these retro-80s brands, however, the secret ingredient is parents' nostalgia - the hope is that as parents watch the show or film with their kids, their warm and fuzzy memories (of the brands they themselves enjoyed as kids) will compell them to try to relive the experience through their children...by buying them the products, bringing them to see the film, etc. This strategy has been gradually building momentum, as 80s kids (the first generation to experience a hyper-commercialized children's culture) have now reached adulthood and are starting to have kids of their own. And I suspect we'll see a lot more of it in the next 5-7 years (as more of us start having families).

Here's the full list of cross-promo initiatives that we can look forward to in the coming months, as provided by KidScreen:
McDonald's: TMNT Happy Meals with eight different premiums will be available and promoted through TV, radio and online campaigns.

Airheads: A special lime-flavored Airhead will be included in 12 million packs of the candies. Each package will also contain a TMNT temporary tattoo. TV spots will tag the promotion.

Time Warner Cable: Time Warner's many media outlets are going to promote a sweepstakes that offers the chance to win a trip to Warner Bros. Studios. Additionally, the company is holding advance screenings in three major US markets and mall events in Dallas and L.A. The TMNT Ubisoft video game is slated to sit at the center of the promos.

Cool Cuts 4 Kids: The salon chain is offering TMNT coloring books, card games and other items, as well as a sweepstakes to win a private screening of the movie. The chain will also distribute advance movie passes in Dallas.

Kmart: Customers who purchase US$10 worth of TMNT movie toys from Playmates Toys will receive an exclusive pack of four collectible trading cards.

Wal-Mart: 1,000 of the chain's top stores are giving away movie posters to every customer who buys a TMNT movie toy.

Toys 'R' Us: Customers who spend US$20 on Playmates Toys' TMNT movie merch will receive a US$5 movie-branded gift card from the chain.

Licensee count: 35 manufacturers are onboard with products ranging from video games (Ubisoft) to apparel (Hot Topic).

Thursday, February 15, 2007

Global Internet Penetration 2006

eMarketer.com has published the most recent statistics on Internet penetration by population (in both millions and %) for a number of countries around the world. While the US still represents the world's largest Internet market (181.9 million), the article predicts that China is likely to "take the lead" within the next couple of years. The world's largest country currently holds the world's second largest market, with 133.5 million online, but at a mere 10.2% penetration rate (compared to the US at 63.6%) China still has a lot of room to grow as Internet access eventually expands into the bulk of its population. Canada continues to rank among the "most connected" countries in the world with a 63.4% penetration rate, just behind the US, Australia (64.5%) and Japan (68.4%). These statistics seem a little low to me (esp. for Canada), so proceed with caution when using them.

There are currently over 1 billion Internet users worldwide, representing 16.6% of the global population.

Speaking Engagement: ACT Book Workshop

Update: You can now access the full program, abstracts as well as (coming soon) audio and video files of the presentations (including mine) on the ACT Lab website. Enjoy!

Next week I will be presenting an overview of the work I've been doing with Andrew Feenberg on expanding instrumentalization theory to the study of digital games, as part of a one-day workshop for the upcoming Applied Communication Technology (ACT) Lab book. Here's the official announcement:

Graduate students in the ACT Lab have been working for a year with Dr. Andrew Feenberg and several of his colleagues on a forthcoming book entitled (Re)Inventing the Internet: Critical Case Studies. This workshop is a report on the progress of their research. The presentations correspond to chapters that explore the social construction of the Internet in a variety of settings, from video games to online education, civic participation to music sharing. The theme is the shaping of the Internet by the practices of users who attempt to influence its design and impact. The Internet appears in these presentations not just as a functional device but also as a field of struggle within which a variety of social and technical factors meet, contend, and converge to produce new forms.

Presenters include noted philosopher of technology Dr. Andrew Feenberg, communication scholar and author of Internet Society Dr. Maria Bakardjieva and Dr. Norm Friesen (Canada Research Chair at Thompson River University). Other panelists include: Ted Hamilton, Cindy Xin, Michael Felczak, Florence Chee, Sara Grimes, Darryl Cressman and Kate Milberry.

Friday, February 23, 2007
Segal Graduate School of Business (500 Granville St.)
4800 Policy Room
10am-4pm

The workshop is co-sponsored by SFU’s School of Communication and the Institute for the Humanities.
Admission is FREE but reservations are required. Call 604-268-7845 to reserve seats.


My presentation will focus on a chapter I'm co-authoring with Andrew called "Rationalizing Play: A critical theory of digital gaming." Here's the abstract:
Despite the rapidly growing body of research and theoretical discussion of digital games and gaming communities, few serious attempts have thus far been made to establish a critical theory of digital game technologies. Yet games exhibit rational features in all societies by their very logic, which implies equality of players whose moves constitute equivalents exchanged under strict classifications and rules according to strategies of optimization with precisely calculable results. In this way, games appear as a realm of rational behaviour long before rationalization overtakes society as a whole. As long as they were limited to individual activities practiced within traditional contexts, however, they did not represent a form of social rationality. With the spread of new forms and practices in digital gaming, particularly the growing participation in massively multiplayer online games (MMOGs) on the Internet, the rational features of games become the basis for the production of a form of social rationality analyzable on terms similar to those employed in the study of technology.

This paper attempts to construct a new framework for the study of games as sites of social rationalization, applying Feenberg's critical theory of technology through an expansion and modification of his concepts of primary and secondary instrumentalization. We begin by making the case for a consideration of games as systems of social rationalization, akin to other modern systems such as capitalist markets and bureaucratic organizations. We then propose a differentiated conceptualization of play that allows us to understand play as a process through which the player focuses attention away from the undifferentiated action of everyday life. This approach also enables us to see how the experience of play changes as it becomes increasingly rationalized through the technological mediation and widespread standardization that occurs as a game becomes a large-scale social practice. Our theoretical framework culminates in the construction of a theory of the rationalization of play, which we have called ludification, which outlines the key components found in all socially rationalizing games. Finally, we will test our theory by applying our framework to the specific example of MMOGs.

MMOGs present a particularly compelling case study, for their players hold a high level of situated knowledge that enables them to engage with digital games technology in a number of ambiguous and unanticipated ways, and as such continue to have tremendous impact on the development, content and function of games within digital culture. Through these unplanned aspects of technical relations the "margin of manoeuvre" of digital games is uncovered, through which, we will argue, players have the potential to truly revolutionize this new medium. As sites of ongoing struggle between players and programmers over the design of the games and usage of the game elements, MMOGs allow for an exploration of ludification that also considers the potential for democratic rationalization inherent within all socially rationalizing systems.

If any of you are in the Vancouver area and would like to attend, I advise reserving asap, as it would seem spaces are quickly filling up. And if any anonymous readers are able to make it, please do introduce yourself to me after the talk!


Updated: Press Coverage of (Re)Inventing the Internet:
"Commerce 'a threat' to democracy of Internet" in the National Post
Same story in the Vancouver Sun
TRU Press Release

UNICEF's Annual Report on Children's Well-Being: Canada Ranks 12

The UN released its annual report on children's well-being in the world's 21 richest (OECD) countries yesterday, showing a continued negligence on the part of powerful nations when it comes to the care of their youngest citizens. While Canada came in 2nd for Education and 6th for Material Well-Being, we scored 12 overall, tied with Greece. This is particularly surprising given that Canada is consistently placed at the top of the UN's Human Development Index (the Quality of Life Survey). With low scores in young people's sense of well-being (15th), risky behaviours (17th), peer/family relationships (18th), and health and safety (13th), Canada will have some work to do before its kids catch up with its adults. We also have a disproportionately large number of families living below the poverty line, a large percentage of which are single-parent households.

Meanwhile, the US and the UK occupied the lowest overall scores, coming in 20th and 21st respectively, with low scores in all six of the measured categories. I can't help but think of the soaring childhood obesity rates in both of these countries, and wonder how much all of these things might be linked. For example, the US scored last in health and safety, which measures things like low birth weight and infant mortality (both of which are often associated with developing countries and low-income groups), but also very low (20th) in peer/family relationships and risky behaviour.

Here's the full list:
1. The Netherlands
2. Sweden
3. Denmark
4. Finland
5. Spain
6. Switzerland
7. Norway
8. Italy
9. Ireland
10. Belgium
11. Germany
12. Canada (tie)
12. Greece (tie)
14. Poland
15. Czech Republic
16. France
17. Portugal
18. Austria
19. Hungary
20. United States
21. United Kingdom


And here are the top scorers for each of the six categories measured:
Material Well-Being: Sweden
Health and Safety: Sweden
Educational Well-Being: Belgium
Family and Peer Relationahips: Italy
Behaviours and Risks: Sweden
Subjective Well-Being: The Netherlands


You can download the report, read the UNICEF press release, or check out this article in yesterday's Globe and Mail (registration may be required after 7 days) for more information.

Monday, February 12, 2007

Lucas, from Star Wars to Lego


(Image reproduced from Gizmondo)

In recognition of his massive contributions to media-driven toy mechandising and the invention of the contemporary action figure, George Lucas was inducted into the toy industry Hall of Fame this weekend. The event both launched the American International Toy Fair and set the tone for the fair's (and the industry's) ongoing emphasis on movie-toy crossovers. Lucas has played a key role in the evolution of children's play culture, primarily by way of his numerous and highly innovative forays into the licensing and merchandising of the Star Wars franchise. The films have supplied a seemingly endless array of characters, creatures, vehicles and starships upon which toys, action figures, LEGO building sets and now video games continue to be based. More importantly, Star Wars was the basis for a new level of cross-media, cross-product, transnational synergy that soon re-set the bar for what a successful kids' media brand could hope to achieve. As Dan Fleming (1996: 96), author of Powerplay: Toys as Popular Culture (one of my comp readings) writes, "[I]nternational merchandising of this kind is a ten-times more lucrative business now than it was before Star Wars...[The release of the first Star Wars film] marks an unmistakable watershed in terms of a much more densely interconnected and interdependent global popular culture of imagery and artifacts."

The bust that LEGO has created in honour of Lucas' induction (seen above) is a particularly apt symbol of Lucas' on-going role in shaping children's play, through both the spread of media-branding into an ever expanding diversity of children's playthings, as well as the close relationship this shares with digitization. LEGO and Star Wars currently enjoy an immensely lucrative partnership, that extends both brands from the physical (LEGO playsets and related merchandise) to the virtual realm (through the LEGO Star Wars video games and highly popular online community). Both incarnations promote a form of narrativised or branded play that in fact encourages kids to appropriate, subvert, and manipulate, but ultimately submit to the thematic motifs and narrative structures provided by the films and related media. Looking again to Fleming's (1996: 104) analysis, we can see how his description of Star Wars brand action figures and toys can easily apply to the LEGO sets and video games as well:
"The narrative elements, or derived 'play scenarios' as Kenner's Star Wars toy designers thought of them, marked a substantially new development in the way children were being encouraged to interact with toys."

While previous TV-based toys encouraged kids to play out scenes or scenarios from the texts themselves,
"these new narrative contexts had multiple narrative possibilities deliberately built into them from the beginning. With clearly established teams of characters and basic story structures..." kids were given the basic tools for the creation of endless plot derivatives, and encouraged to do so.

I'm not sure what exactly to make of all this, but I do like "narrativised play" as a concept. I find it much more suitable to the malleable, semi-empowering forms of branded play that are currently so popular among the children's industries--play that integrates real opportunities for agency and creativity (and user-generated content) within the overarching, oppressive authority of a well-defined media (or consumer) brand.

You can read the Lucas Film press release from back in May (when the announcement was first made) here.

Or click here for a fascinating story about LEGO Education Centers via KidScreen.

Saturday, February 10, 2007

Cyberkids at the Toy Fair

The American International Toy Fair starts next week (Feb. 11-14) and this year everyone is all "a buzz" about " high tech"...again! Part of this is a result of the ongoing celebratory discourse around tech-savvy "cyberkids" (which promotes the idea that if kids are encouraged to develop their innate technological skills they will be better prepared for a future as IT workers), but mostly the industry seems to be responding to consumer trends. The US toy industry grew for the first time in ages last year (to $22.3 billion), primarily due to a 22% increase in the "youth electronics" category--which grew from $871.5 million (2005) to $1.1 billion (2006). (Note: That's not including video games, which have their own category and represented an additional $12.5 billion last year in the US alone). The Toy Fair (as it's called) is a big deal for toy manufacturers and retailers, who are now dealing with a $60 billion global industry which remains dominated by US toy companies (Mattel and Hasbro are the biggest in the world, with Japanese companies Bandai and Sanrio, and Denmark's Lego rounding out the top five), and by US retailers (Wal-Mart and Toys'R'US are the top two toy sellers in the world (in that order)).

As toy trend specialist Reyne Rice describes, "About four to five years ago we saw that kids were starting to leave the toy industry for four main areas: music, fashion, electronics and entertainment. So by bringing those play patterns into products that are suitable and accessible for kids -- and priced for families' wallets -- the youth electronics aisle has exploded with those types of products."

While tech toys are seemingly nothing new, it appears that their dominance over this year's Toy Fair is worthy of note. I also noticed two key themes in the press and corporate discourse around the event so far that I think are worth exploring:

1. Toying with Technology
The first key theme is a sort of dumbing down or "toy-ification" of existing technologies that are believed to be popular among kids. This is immediately apparent in Gelfand's Wired coverage, wherein he states: "[T]oy manufacturers will be introducing a host of adult technologies aimed at small children -- including kid-friendly laptops, graphics tablets, digital cameras and a host of other high-tech items." A good example is the ClickStart laptop for kids, which consists of a toy computer that plugs into the TV instead of into real computer applications or the internet. According to Chris Byrne (the "Toy Guy"), "Kids insist on being on the computer, and giving them one that satisfies that desire to be like mom and dad, and have a computer, but one that connects to the TV, is really good" (cited in MarketWatch).

I see here a fascinating contradiction - on the one hand, there's this urge to have the child play with technology, but on the other hand the implication is that real technologies are for adults. Instead of really engaging with the technologies themselves, these toys encourage kids to "play" at or role-play using the computer. A sort of Easy-Bake Oven for the digital age. Of course, the idea to have kids "play" at computers is an attempt to safely replicate the widespread reality of kids playing on computers. By transforming a new and perhaps threatening relationship, that of children-and-technology, into the more traditionally understood relationship of "children and toy", the notion of the cyberchild is reconstituted in familiar terms--where the parent retains authority over technology, and the child's activities are redirected towards the contained space of the playroom.

2. Enclosure
The second trend involves toys and software aimed at constraining existing technologies to give parents a sense of control over their children’s technologically-mediated activities. Three new toys in particular stand out in this regard, Mattel/Fisher-Price’s Easy-Link Internet Launchpad (which plugs into your PC’s USB, and acts as a portal and internet filter to ensure kids can only access certain age-appropriate websites…perhaps primarily those created by Mattel???), Vtech’s V.Space online (an educational desktop application), and Hasbro/Tiger Games’ Net Jet (an online gaming system for pre-teens). Again, the emphasis is on control, though in this case the toy/software integrates existing technologies (such as the internet) but in a highly limited way. Thus, kids can go on the internet, but can only visit certain websites and engage in certain types of activities. As with the previous batch, however, I fear that the social construction of these new technological artefacts positions children in a very specific and highly ideological way. While the celebratory discourse around kids and technology remains an underlying factor here (it is, after all, the aura), the relationship is perceived as something that must be contained, enclosed, stopped and modified. The creative aspects seem to be left out almost completely (although there are some art/graphics games that encourage creativity with digital art), as are the social and cultural aspects of going online to play with other kids or to participate in a new form of cultural production. Instead, kids’ digital play is re-interpreted as a highly purposeful and primarily commercialized form of play. The emphasis on education is no coincidence—the desire to transform children’s online play, as Ellen Seiter describes, into a productive pursuit is obvious within these toys which seek to appropriate the relationship by selling parents the magic beans of the digital age: safety and education.

Here are the full articles for the Wired, and MarketWatch coverage.

Thursday, February 08, 2007

"S" is for Sesame Street


The Kidscreen Summit is going on right now, providing an endless stream of children's media related news items. In particular, two announcements from the Sesame Workshop have caught my eye. For a number of years now, Sesame Workshop (formerly the Children's Television Workshop) has had full-run of the Sesame Street franchise, using it to propel research, educational curriculum, and a staggeringly significant global kids' media brand. The show itself has had some ups and downs over the years, but continues to be both a critical success and a huge audience draw. For example, as of 2005, it had won over 100 Emmy Awards, the most awards given to any one show in the US (and last year, it won 8 more). It's also won awards and praise from a variety of organizations, governments and NGOs, both domestically and abroad (even Kofi Anon digs it!). It's the most-watched children's television program in the world (though I can't find the stats on total audience reach, which is too bad) and airs in over 140 countries.

(BTW: It was just nominated again for several Emmys, including Outstanding Pre-School Children's Series, Outstanding Directing in a Children's Series, 2 nominations for Outstanding Performer in a Children's Series (one for Caroll Spinney, as Oscar the Grouch, and one for Kevin Clash, as Elmo), and Outstanding Writing in a Children's Series.).

The first announcement is that Sesame Workshop, in conjunction with German networks NDR and Ki.Ka as well as Five's Milkshake in the UK, will be launching a new claymation spin-off series called The Adventures of Bert and Ernie, set to air in 2008. The show represents something of a jump for Sesame Street into a new genre, but the company fully intends to maintain its brand identity. As KidScreen magazine describes:
"We want to bring Sesame Street into the 21st Century, but, we're not ready to make huge changes to the overall show and brand," says Jennifer Monier-Williams,VP of global television distribution for Sesame Workshop. Accompanying the German and UK deals, presales have been made to ABC (Australia), Cartoon Network India, DBC (Denmark), Disney Asia, Disney Spain, HOP (Israel), NPS/Zeppelin (Netherlands), NRK (Norway), and SVT (Sweden). Interestingly, there is no US broadcast deal in the works, but look for the segments to pop up on DVD releases and in special promotions.

The second announcement (also courtesy of KidScreen) deals more directly with Sesame Street's global media project, in particular a community-focused website called Panwapa (and accompanying DVD) that aims to teach kids about globalization and their roles as global citizens. The site will consist of a portal, hosted by six new Muppets created specifically for the program, and will emphasize social issues and responsibilities. As KidScreen describes:
The site's users will be encouraged to set up their own "Me Page" that will include a personalized avatar, a home-country setting, and a list of interest topics to choose from, including favorite food, animal and musical instrument. Interactive games, such as treasure hunts where participants will be asked to search out citizens who like peanut butter sandwiches, for example, will also be part of the site. The end goal is to get kids thinking about the world as a diverse place, full of different languages, cultures and economic circumstances.


These new international projects got me thinking about how problematic Sesame Street is as a case study in media globalization. Here is a cross-media, totally synergized children's media brand, that exports its programming around the world, oftentimes with state or NGO assistance as a result of its promise that television can be used to teach young children basic literacy and academic skills. As a media megabrand, Sesame Street traverses into other media forms (from direct-to-video, to computer software, to books and in-school programming), and is heavily involved in merchandising and licensing (just think of the massive success of the Tickle-Me Elmo dolls, or all the products, toys and accessories that bear the images of the Sesame Street characters). In 2005 alone, the Sesame Workshop made $96 million, 68% of which was generated by licensing and merchandising spin-offs. When analyzed from a political economic perspective, the Sesame Workshop is every bit as commercial and imperialistic as Disney or Pokemon.

Yet, Sesame Workshop's particular brand of globalization often involves localized versions of Sesame Street that are co-produced with local creative teams. In so doing, they have often succeeded in creating locally sustainable and culturally-inclusive children's programming. They're also at the forefront of promoting awareness of social issues using child-friendly language and themes, taking on HIV/AIDS in South Africa and ethnic tensions in Kosovo. The contents of the show/brand itself represent children's television at its finest--its fun storylines and engaging characters, age-appropriate themes, probably educational emphasis on language, letters and math (although this is one of the issues under debate), and its commitment to children's own cultural experience and concerns. From this perspective, it suddenly becomes very difficult to clump the Sesame Workshop in with those other global media brands. This is truly an example of corporate identity clashing with financial reality, and (I think) a particularly clear example of the tension between cultural studies and political economy.

A great way to explore this further is to watch The World According to Sesame Street, a documentary film released last year by Participant Productions (the same peeps who brought us Syriana and An Inconvenient Truth). While the film, an official selection at the 2006 Sundance Film Festival, is certainly not an overly critical examination of Sesame Street's own felt-coated brand of cultural imperialism, it does provide a nice counterbalance when juxtaposed with the literature on (evil) globalization and political economy. I fully intend to use this film once I start teaching, as a way of demonstrating the grey areas of globalization...that not everyone involved is doing so for the sole dark purpose of exploitation...and yet that this can nontheless be the consequence of even the best intended projects.

Here are some additional academic sources on the issue:
Moran, Kristin (2006). The global expansion of children’s television: a case study of the adaptation of Sesame Street in Spain. Learning, Media & Technology 31(3): 287-300.

Fisch, Shalom M. and Rosemarie T. Truglio (eds.) (2000). "G" Is for Growing: Thirty Years of Research on Children and Sesame Street. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.

Hendershot, Heather (2000)Sesame Street: Cognition and Communications Imperialism, pp.139-176 in Kinder, Marsha (ed.) Kids Media Culture. Duke University Press.

And here's an article on Sesame Workshop'snew distribution deal with Genius Products/The Weinstein Company, as well as an article on how to submit shorts for inclusion in the series.

Wednesday, February 07, 2007

Okami Nominated for Best Game 2006

Second posting today, I know, but the GDC nominations are out! Yay! I am SO excited about this nomination for Okami. Although I embarassingly haven't had a chance to play it yet, it looks and sounds absolutely amazing, as you can tell from the WomenGamers review. But most importantly, it's a stark departure from the usual testosterone-fueled war and/or sports games that usually get all the props. In fact, the Game Developer Choice Awards nominees are fairly well-rounded this year, with Gears of War, Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion, The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess and Wii Sports rounding out the list for best game, Bully getting a nom for writing, and Viva Pinata earning itself 3 design-related noms (character design, game design and visual arts).

Children and Media Risk

A number of articles and reports have come out this week focusing on the many ways that children are "under threat," a couple of which offer both interesting findings and some good insight into adults' ongoing worries about kids and technology. The first is a report by market research group Insight Media, on the things parents worry about the most when it comes to their kids. The article from Associated Content reads:
Modern day parents are more worried about their kids' consumption of TV and the Internet than they are about their their kids' involvement with sex or drugs according to a recent studied conducted by Insight Media Group.

Specifically, parents are worried about their kids' "overuse of media" including social networking, downloading music, playing video games, and and of course, watching TV.

Overuse of TV, not the Internet, is still TV that made the top list of parental concerns in regard to media overuse, according to the study.

Percentages attributed to each type of media, and parental concern of its overuse:

29% Television
24% Internet
18% Video Games

I suppose that television's near ubiquitous presence in children's homes is what puts it at the top of the list here, although there's also been continued rumblings about high levels of violence and commercialization on TV, which may relate to this "concern." As always, video games are up there in the top 3, though didn't score quite as high as I would have expected.

The second report hails from the EU, where mobile phone manufacturers have banded together to make phones "safer" for kids. No, they're not implementing some new protective shielding to protect kids brains from potentially harmful radiofrequency energy (RF) exposure. Instead they're tackling issues related to access - namely other people's access to kids through mobile phone technologies. From the MAGIC mailing list:
A group of more than a dozen European mobile phone companies signed an agreement to help make mobile phones safer for children. The Framework on Safer Mobile Use was developed in response to a European Commission study on child safety and mobile phones. Threats to children via mobile phones include bullying, sexual grooming for abuse, access to pornographic and violent content and privacy risks.
[...]
By signing the European Framework on Safer Mobile Use by Younger Teenagers and Children, the mobile phone companies agreed to support access control for adult content, awareness-raising campaigns for parents and children, the classification of commercial content according to national standards of decency and appropriateness, and the fight against illegal content on mobile phones. The agreement, brokered by the European Commission, calls on the companies to develop national self-regulatory codes by February 2008.

Tuesday, February 06, 2007

Kids' Media Synergy Gets a Little Slap in the Face

My fixation on the newly proposed FCC requirements for kids' websites has resulted in one heck of an oversight, missing the boat on this new rule banning kids' television channels from promoting websites with commercial content (ads). Here's the CNET News story, courtesy of Chris Schuepp from the Young People's Media Network at UNICEF:
Kids' TV faces new Net restrictions
Feds want to keep commercial Web site references out of children's programming, but some say the rules don't go far enough.

By Anne Broache - Staff Writer, CNET News.com - Published: January 24, 2007, 9:51 AM PST

CNN can promote its advertisement-laced online presence however it likes during broadcasts, but new federal rules mean TV channels like Nickelodeon that cater to children no longer enjoy the same freedom. The Federal Communications Commission decreed that during shows geared toward children age 12 and under, cable and broadcast operators may not display addresses for Web sites that contain any links to commercial content. The rules took effect on January 2.

Never mind that recent visits to NickJr.com and Noggin.com, online properties of kid networks, turned up more advertisements for Tylenol cold medicine and Nissan minivans than for anything youth-targeted. And some child advocacy groups would argue that many kids' television shows amount to program-length commercials for the toys and edible goodies endorsed by their stars.

You can access the full article here. Notice how the age range for media regulation is getting smaller and younger...interesting. I wonder what this will mean for all those kidnet MMOG projects, but then again these new initiatives might even be strategically designed to compensate for this new rule. If the site is big and fun enough, they may not need to rely as much on traditional forms of advertising to lure kids in.

Sunday, February 04, 2007

Hi Hi Puffy AmiYumi Takes Over my DS

If you've ever seen Japanese import Hi Hi Puffy AmiYumi Show, starring J-pop duo Puffy (Ami Onuki and Yumi Yoshimura) and their cartoon selves, taking on bad guys while rocking the house, you'll understand my excitement to play Hi Hi Puffy AmiYumi: The Genie and the Amp (for Nintendo DS) when I came across it last week in the discount bin at Superstore. Not because I thought it would be especially well-designed or particularly challenging, but because--having seen the show--I knew this would be one heck of a bizarro game. And boy am I ever not disappointed.

Switching between Ami and Yumi, and with the aid of a watch-your-copyright-infringement genie, you set out on a time travelling adventure to find musical inspiration by wacking creatures and musical geniuses with an electric guitar. You accomplish said wacks by churning out tunes on 5 guitar strings, which you can also "strum" into chords using your stylus. The "bad guys" are a motley crew, following in the theme of each location and time period. So, for Japan circa "the day before yesterday", I had to fend off 2D arcade karate dudes...how very postmodern....and in 1994 Slovenia, it's all skeletons and vampires. Another level features garden gnomes, but I don't really get why. There's a LOT I don't get about this game, which is what makes it so fun. Each level has special guitars for the girls and millieu-appropriate outfits you can buy in vending machines dispersed throughout the game. But even better than that is collecting ingredients for sushi, which you then get to roll yourself between levels. I can now see why Cooking Mama is such a massive hit - cutting virtual fish to make sushi rolls is surprisingly satisfying.

You can check out the trailer here or read the Gamespot reviews here.

Thursday, February 01, 2007

Dance Dance Revolution

There was a lot of hoopla last year when, following a successful pilot project conducted the previous year, West Virginia decided the use popular dance game Dance Dance Revolution to supplement underfunded gym programs across its public school system, and respond to the state's massive child obesity problem. The West Virginia Games For Health project has now released the results of a year-long study into the outcome of this initiative, which you can find here, courtesy of Gamasutra. From the article:
The researchers have found that although not all of the children lost weight, the majority did not gain weight while experiencing improvements in their aerobic capacity, blood vessel function and overall fitness level. Just as significantly, their attitudes towards exercise improved as did their self esteem. Murphy pointed out that, "Most of our subjects had historically felt awkward about participating in gym and physical activity at school. After the program, they demonstrated a new sense of confidence and desired to maintain their new found skills."

Dr. Murphy was also quoted as saying:
"This Institutional Review Board approved study has now provided evidence that consistent playing of DDR improves arterial function in overweight children."

Good for West Virginia for finding a fun way to get kids more active, though it's kind of sad to think of the state of affairs that has led to the necessity of such a project. For those of you that are still skeptical about using a video game to increase kids' physical activity (instead of promoting more traditional forms of sport and exercise), I should point out that it is the opinion of one of the project's primary sponsors (the Public Employees Insurance Agency - kinda creepy but predictable that the insurance industry is getting in on this issue) that children in West Virginia do not currently have the same opportunities for healthy eating and exercise as children from more advantaged areas.

The shrinking space for children's play (and mere presence) in public places and urban areas is often ignored as a possible contributor to childhood obesity, but if kids have nowhere to run around and be active, how are they supposed to get any exercise? Opportunities for children's physical activity are often limited to structured activities, such as soccer practice and ballet--which are usually pretty expensive--and gym class, which is severely underfunded in the majority of public schools, particularly those in disadvantaged areas. The correlation between socio-economic status and obesity is no coincidence. Not only are unhealthy foods more accessible to lower-income families than the healthy alternatives, but opportunities for exercise, especially in urban areas, are often positively linked with income. Besides which, I'm a big supporter of the "kids' play should be fun" approach.

On the other hand, if you doubt that a video game can be sufficiently active to have any health benefits, check out this kid!